A pencil popper is the most versatile top water plug. A pencil popper can be fished in the surf, in inlets, in clam conditions, in rough conditions, during the day, and at night. I fish Guppy pencil poppers because they are well built, field tested, and optimized for casting distance and action.
Wayne Hess, the owner of Guppy Lures, makes five different pencil poppers that range from 1 1/4 oz to 3 1/2 oz. Each Guppy pencil popper is hand built with through-wire construction. A 1/16″ diameter stainless steel wire is passed through the center of the plug. The belly hook is a VMC 4X treble hook (1/0 to 4/0) that is secured to a Krok stainless steel barrel swivel (220 lb to 500 lbs) via Wolverine split ring. The tail hook is also a VMC 4X treble hook (1/0 to 4/0) that is secured to through-wire via Wolverine split ring. Each plug is painted in one of 19 different color patterns using a complex process that incorporates a sealer to eliminate water intrusion, primer, and a clear coat.
I have caught fish in inlets with a round bottom pencil popper. I have caught fish in the surf with a flat bottom pencil popper. Both styles catch fish in the surf and in inlets. But! If I have room for only one pencil popper in my plug bag, it’s going to a Guppy flat bottom (a.k.a. “Canal Special”) pencil popper. Why? Because they casts farther. Their flat bottoms allow the plug to rise to the surf quickly after they sink into the water at the end of the cast.
Some pencil poppers on the market require some modifications before use. For example, replacing weak split rings and fragile hooks. The only modification that I make to my Guppy pencil poppers is to replace the rear treble hook with a custom tied VMC siwash hook. I tie my own tails in matching colors using a multi-layered threading and epoxy process. This small modification enhances the action and extends the color profile of the plug.
Do you own a Guppy pencil popper? If you do not, buy one! If you do, but another one!! Fish them in inlets. Fish them in the surf. Be sure to hold onto your rod….the strikes are explosive!!!